WASHINGTON, D.C. — Two competing legislative proposals aimed at providing disaster relief failed to advance in the Senate on Monday amid a fight over funding for hurricane-ravaged Puerto Rico.
The Senate first voted on a GOP proposal that Democrats objected to because they argued it did not provide adequate aid for Puerto Rico. That vote was 44-49. The second measure that came up for a vote was a relief measure that passed out of the Democratic-controlled House months ago. Republicans criticized that legislation for not providing relief for recent flooding that has devastated the Midwest. That vote was 46-48.
The failure of both measures will send lawmakers back to the drawing board in search of a compromise that can pass. It also puts lawmakers from both sides of the aisle in a politically precarious position and opens senators up to attacks from the opposing party accusing them of blocking much-needed disaster aid.
The GOP legislation authored by Senate Appropriations Chairman Richard Shelby would allocate roughly $13.5 billion for rebuilding and recovery from natural disasters such as tornadoes, earthquakes, hurricanes and wildfires. The legislation includes $600 million to pay for nutrition assistance for Puerto Rico.
Democrats opposed the Republican Senate proposal in part, because they argue it does not include enough aid for hurricane-ravaged Puerto Rico. Republicans, meanwhile, have criticized Democrats for their opposition by pointing to the fact that the House-passed legislation does not include relief for recent flooding that has devastated the Midwest.
Senate Republican leader Mitch McConnell called the House bill a “non-starter” in remarks on the Senate floor on Monday because, he said, it provides “nothing for Midwest flooding.”
Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer attacked the GOP position in advance of the vote Monday.
“Republican senators are attempting to strip away recovery funds from Puerto Rico and other territories from the disaster package that passed the House,” Schumer said on the Senate floor on Monday. The top Senate Democrat described the administration’s response to the devastating impact hurricanes have had on Puerto Rico as “cruel” and “nasty,” and said, “President Trump tweets while Puerto Rico suffers.”
President Donald Trump later accused Democrats of hurting mainland US farmers for the sake of additional aid for Puerto Rico while also renewing his long-running criticisms of the island’s leadership.
“91 Billion Dollars to Puerto Rico, and now the Dems want to give them more, taking dollars away from our Farmers and so many others,” tweeted Trump, who last week took a swipe at the amount of federal funding headed to Puerto Rico during a closed door meeting with Seate Republicans. “Disgraceful!”
Democrats have argued that the GOP relief effort provides insufficient funding for Puerto Rico because it fails to include a variety of measures that were part of the roughly $14.2 billion relief package passed by Democrats who control the House in January. Those measures include state revolving funds that could be used by Puerto Rico to rebuild water systems that have sustained damage as well as a 100% cost share for the Federal Emergency Management Agency that Democrats say would unlock federal aid for Puerto Rico.
Puerto Rico’s Democratic governor, Ricardo Rossello, has also weighed in on the disaster relief debate, saying in a statement over the weekend that the Senate should pass the House-passed relief measure. The governor said that legislation “provides much-needed support to Puerto Rico in addressing critical infrastructure, education, nutritional and housing needs on the island.”
Republicans, on the other hand, have argued that blocking the legislation would hurt the states and territories that would receive relief if it passes and would amount to Democrats holding those impacted communities’ hostage.
The Senate GOP legislation includes relief for disasters that have taken place this year such as aid for Midwestern states like Iowa and Nebraska that have experienced damaging floods.
The House disaster relief legislation passed several months ago and as a result did not include relief for those more recent disasters, which have taken place in recent weeks.
Shelby said last Thursday that he hopes the Republican bill isn’t filibustered by Democrats.
“There are a lot of people out there who are deserving and hurting everywhere, including in Puerto Rico,” he said.
If Democrats block the GOP proposal, they could gain leverage in their push to get the President to agree to more funding for Puerto Rico, but they also risk being tagged with the blame for stalling much-needed aid for other areas hard-hit by natural disasters.
Even if Democrats did agree to clear the GOP measure through the Senate, the dispute over funding for Puerto Rico would not be over. The bill would then need to go to a conference committee with the Democrats who control the House and who are also pushing for additional funding for Puerto Rico.
House Democrats have also said they oppose the Senate Republican relief effort, arguing, like Senate Democrats, that it provides insufficient aid to Puerto Rico.
If the bill fails to pass out of the Senate, negotiations about a path forward on disaster relief will need to continue.
Senate Democrats have also proposed passing a “shell bill” and sending it to conference where differences between Democrats and Republicans could be resolved.