WASHINGTON — Donald Trump faces a test of resilience on Tuesday as four more nominating contests, including the important Michigan battleground, unfold alongside a quickening last ditch-bid by his foes to slow his march to the Republican nomination.
Democrat Hillary Clinton, meanwhile, hopes to register a win in Michigan to make a point about rival Bernie Sanders’ limits after he won three weekend caucuses but failed to close her lead in pledged delegates or to turn the campaign in his favor.
Republicans are voting on what is being dubbed Super Tuesday 2 in primaries in Michigan, Idaho and Mississippi and in caucuses in Hawaii with 150 delegates up for grabs. Democrats hold contests in Michigan and Mississippi, where Clinton is expected to extend her dominance of the South. She and Sanders are fighting for 166 delegates on Tuesday. The former secretary of state holds an overall lead of around 200 pledged delegates over Sanders, whose spirited campaign has enlivened grass-roots Democrats and tugged her to the left on some key issues.
The biggest prize
Michigan is the biggest prize on Tuesday in both races. The state will offer clues about the appeal of the leading candidates among blue collar voters in the industrial Midwest and may hold omens for significant looming primaries in states like Ohio and Illinois.
The state looms as particularly important for Trump following anecdotal evidence that fierce attacks on his character and qualifications by other candidates and the Republican establishment may be beginning to have an impact. The billionaire’s margin of victory was smaller than expected in Louisiana and Kentucky over the weekend and there were signs of widening support for his closest rival in the delegate count, Texas Sen. Ted Cruz, who shrugged off a disappointing showing on Super Tuesday last week.
Still, a Monmouth University poll of Michigan on Monday showed Trump with a big lead and again benefitting from a split opposition against him. The front-runner was at 36%, Cruz was second on 23%, Ohio Gov. John Kasich had 21% and Florida Sen. Marco Rubio was at 13%.
A big win in Michigan is important for Trump because it would offer evidence for his argument that he is uniquely qualified among Republicans to attract swing voters in rust belt states and to expand the party’s general election coalition.
“I’m not a normal Republican,” Trump said last week in Macomb County, the place where the fabled phenomenon of Reagan Democrats, who dropped their party affiliation to side with the Republican president, was first identified.
“A normal Republican cannot think in terms … of bringing in Michigan. And if you don’t bring in Michigan it’s tough. You have a very narrow road,” Trump said.
Trump will be helped on Tuesday by the fact that both Michigan and Mississippi have open primaries, meaning that Democrats and independents attracted by his message can vote in the Republican contest. Cruz, currently the best placed challenger to Trump, has tended to do better in closed races, where only registered GOP voters can take part and where conservatives hold more sway. The Texas senator, however, will be looking for a strong performance in Mississippi and a second place finish in Michigan to bolster his case that he — and not Rubio — is the only viable alternative to Trump.
Important moment for Kasich
Tuesday’s races also represent an important moment for Kasich, who owing to his lack of appeal in the South has spent several weeks effectively on the sidelines following a strong second place showing in the New Hampshire primary last month, but has spent several weeks effectively on the sidelines during Southern primaries where has proven to be less popular.
Michigan may also be a barometer of Kasich’s prospects in his own state of Ohio next week, which is a make or break contest for him.
And despite winning the Puerto Rico primary for his second victory of the campaign on Sunday, Rubio appears to be headed for another tough night.
Rules requiring a candidate to reach a threshold to get a share of the delegates on offer in the three primary states on Tuesday could see him fall further behind Cruz, who has already suggested his fellow senator should get out of the race.
Michigan test for Democrats
Sanders, fresh from a testy debate with Clinton on Sunday, needs a strong showing to deprive his opponent’s campaign of an argument that not only can he not win southern states but he is lagging behind in diverse Midwestern ones as well.
The Monmouth poll found Clinton leading 55% to 42% going into the primary, and she has begun to gently make the case that it might be time for Sanders, who has vowed to fight on until the Democratic convention, to consider his position.
“The sooner I could become your nominee, the more I could begin to turn attention to the Republicans,” Clinton told supporters on Monday.
Sanders was stung by Clinton’s claim in their most recent debate in Flint, Michigan, on Sunday night that he voted against an auto-bailout for the U.S. auto industry — a key local employer — when it was teetering on the edge of extinction in early 2009.
But the Sanders campaign has accused Clinton of being disingenuous, saying he had voted to support a $14 billion auto industry aid package in 2008, but opposed the measure later being folded into a Wall Street bailout bill that he did not support.
The Vermont Senator has also hammered Clinton for her support for free trade agreements that he says have badly hit manufacturing in states like Michigan.
“What these trade agreements have done is decimated communities all across America,” Sanders said in the state on Monday.
“I have helped lead the opposition to every one of these disastrous trade agreements because I knew what they would do with America.”